Ashok Aklujkar
Authorship of the Saṅkarṣa-kāṇḍa, in Devadattīyam (Bern: Fritz Lang, 2012), 193--194
Authorship of the Saṅkarṣa-kāṇḍa, in Devadattīyam (Bern: Fritz Lang, 2012), 193--194
Using expressions like “it seems unlikely” or “I am not convinced” without specifying the reason for their use is a bane of historical research writing. Unfortunately this practice, which can mislead a reader into thinking that a counter-argument has been made when in fact no argument has been made, is not rare in Indology. The ultimate import of expressions of the specified kind is usually “I, the researcher, am not willing to change my view, even if your argument is sound” or “I, the researcher, am not going to be so adventurous as to differ from the majority or mainstream view, even when the erroneous nature of that view has been exposed”.
Comments and discussions are welcome. Be sure you are making a point and contributing to the discussion.